What a trademark examiner reviews
The examiner applies the law and filing requirements of the relevant office. Examination includes more than checking that all boxes are filled in. Before responding, separate formal requirements from objections about the mark itself and conflicts with earlier rights.
- Owner and application details: the correct applicant, required contact information and filing particulars.
- The sign: its representation, any required description, and whether it functions as a trademark.
- Goods and services: clear, accurate wording and appropriate classification.
- Substantive requirements: distinctiveness, descriptiveness, prohibited matter and relevant earlier marks.
- Country-specific evidence: for example, the U.S. filing basis and any required specimens or use statements. Do not assume the same evidence is required in Canada.
Waiting time changes. Consult the USPTO processing pages for U.S. applications and CIPO’s dated examination forecast for Canada. Time to a first examination is not time to registration, and an old 4- or 8-month estimate is not a deadline for a new filing.
One Example Situation: Challenges Trademarking Your Brand
This story is an example of the kinds of challenges that can come up when trademarking your brand.
I am going to tell you a story. We had a client; we filed 5 trademarks for them. The trademark applications were almost identical, the only difference was the trademarks themselves were different. And it so happens that 3 of these applications ended up on the desk of one trademark examiner, and two of them ended up on the desk of another.
And our client was in the telecommunications services field. So the first examiner, the one who got the 3 applications, they were very happy with everything, they approved the applications right away, with no problems, no questions asked. The second examiner was giving us hell.
The trademarks were ok, it was the list of products and services that they were not happy with. They said it wasn't specific enough. And the phrase that they were particularly annoyed by was, "transmission of data over the Internet".
And the examiner goes, "What kind of data?"
We're like, "Any data!"
They go, "No, no it's not specific enough."
So we changed that to "transmission of images, text, video, multimedia and other content over the Internet."
Several months later, we get another office action from the same examiner saying that it was still not specific enough. "What is the text about? What are the videos about?"
I was like, "Are you kidding me? Why are you asking us all these questions? It does not make any sense! The other examiner who saw the same thing was ok with that."
And the trademark examiner said, "I don't care what the other examiner said, I don't understand what the text is about. And you need to specify that."
How Expertise Can Resolve This Situation and Capitalize Trademark Costs
So we realized that we can't argue with that person, because it was a completely unreasonable request. So what we did is we wrote a letter to the Trademarks Office and asked, almost begged, for the 2 trademark applications to be sent to the same examiner who just approved 3 other applications.
And we were lucky enough that we had more than one, and so they agreed, and those applications were approved, and the client's trademarks are now registered.
This account illustrates an issue that arose in a particular file. It does not establish that reassignment is normally available or that a result in one application binds an examiner in another. The response should address the actual requirement, governing law and supporting evidence.
How an Examiner Helps Trademarking Your Brand
Examination can involve judgment, and reasonable disagreements may arise. Identify the objection precisely, read the cited law or guidance and respond with relevant facts and evidence. Personal criticism of an examiner is not a substitute for addressing the issue. No representative controls the office’s decision.
So there is a lot of subjectivity, that's why there is never 100% certainty as to whether your trademark is going to go through. Even if we can’t guarantee 100% in getting approved, we're still going to offer you a 100% money-back guarantee (if we think that the likelihood of objections is relatively low.) But it does not mean that we're 100% certain that the trademark examiner on the other side is going to approve that.
Formalities include required application information and acceptable representations. Whether a mark is descriptive or distinctive is a substantive question, not simply a formality. The examiner also reviews relevant earlier marks and the relationship between the goods or services.
Different industries or class numbers do not automatically rule out confusion. Compare the signs and goods or services in their legal context. An Office action should be answered issue by issue, with permitted amendments and evidence where appropriate.
The Importance of Communication and Perseverance in Trademarking Your Brand
And that's really what our job is, to communicate with them. Well, the first step of our job is to attempt to draft your application so that they say, "Yes, it's a perfect application, we are happy, we approve it right away."
Ideally, more applications would be processed quickly this way. Unfortunately, it doesn't happen very often. Not because we don't know what we're doing, we've filed hundreds and hundreds of trademarks, I have people who work for me, who have filed thousands and thousands of trademarks. So we do know what we're doing, it's just that there's this level of subjectivity.
How much does it cost to apply for a trademark? We’ll do everything we can to make sure it’s the lowest amount possible by getting it approved the first time if at all possible. So the first thing we do is try to file a trademark so that it goes through and gets approved right away.
And if it doesn't, then our job is to keep at it, and argue with them, and fix the application, and tweak the application, and do all those things to make sure that the brand that you entrusted us with gets registered, and that you have something that you could hang on your wall in a frame and say, "This brand is mine!" We do everything we can to make sure trademarking your brand gets done.